Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The power of protest
By Martin J Young

HUA HIN, Thailand - The Internet community united this week in protest at two United States anti-piracy bills that, if approved, could result in unprecedented levels of online censorship. The congressional bills, Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and Protect Intellectual Property Act (PIPA), are backed by major media companies in an effort to restrict illegal downloading and streaming of TV shows and movies from the Internet.

If implemented, the bills would grant power to limit access to and block websites deemed to be allowing the distribution of copyright material.

Critics say the definitions involved are too broad, such as the term "search engine", which could result in entire websites being taken offline for having links to material hosted elsewhere. The primary concern is that the US would be building its own Great Firewall, giving it a stranglehold on the web, starting with SOPA and PIPA. This heavy-handed approach would result in a cloak of censorship across the globe.

On Wednesday, a number of major players on the Internet went dark and shut down their websites for a 24-hour protest. Wikipedia replaced its home page with a black screen and the message "For over a decade, we have spent millions of hours building the largest encyclopedia in human history. Right now, the US Congress is considering legislation that could fatally damage the free and open Internet. For 24 hours, to raise awareness, we are blacking out Wikipedia."

Google joined in by prompting people to sign a petition [1] and stating, "The most effective way to shut down pirate websites is through targeted legislation that cuts off their funding. There's no need to make American social networks, blogs and search engines censor the Internet or undermine the existing laws that have enabled the Web to thrive, creating millions of US jobs."

At the time of writing, 4.5 million Internet users had signed the petition, according to Google, and over 3 million messages on the subject made it onto Twitter. The protest began to snowball mid-week, with others, including Craigslist, Facebook, Yahoo's Flikr and Reddit, voicing their opposition against the proposed legislation. Several other Internet companies, including AOL, eBay, LinkedIn, Mozilla, Yahoo and Zynga, wrote a letter to the US Congress highlighting the implications on job creation and innovation in the industry.

Real-world protests also began in earnest as people took to the streets of New York, San Francisco and Las Vegas to raise awareness of SOPA and PIPA and the danger they present to a free and open Internet.

United States senators and politicians in favor of the acts have labeled the web blackout a "publicity stunt" and "gimmick", promoting fear instead of fact.

Supporters of the bills, including Hollywood movie industry leaders, the US Chamber of Commerce, Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation and the Motion Picture Association of America, claim that they are necessary to protect content providers being plagiarized by rogue websites beyond the enforcement reach of US authorities.

Google pointed out that censorship regulations wouldn't shut down rogue websites as they would just change their addresses and continue their criminal activities, while law-abiding companies would suffer high penalties for breaches they could not possibly control.

Following one of the largest digital protests in recent times, political support for the two bills began to wane, with a number of senators previously in favor of them voicing reservations and stating that there was a lack of consensus on them. The power of protest this week has proved at least one thing: that the Internet has politically come of age.

Security
Cyber skirmishes in the Middle East escalated this week as Israel and its neighbors exchanged digital blows on the Internet. Just days after an unidentified hacker with proclaimed Palestinian sympathies posted thousands of Israeli credit card details stolen from an e-commerce site, Israel came under attack in what the government has called a cyber-offensive.

Hackers targeted the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange, El Al Airlines and three banks causing intermittent access and services. Stock trading and banking services were not affected, though the First International Bank of Israel did block international access to its website as a security precaution.

Deputy Foreign Minister Daniel Ayalon stated that Israel would respond, as it usually does, by striking back with force against the attackers. Hackers going by the name IDF-Team wasted no time in targeting websites of the Saudi Stock Exchange and the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange in retaliation.

As political tensions continue to build in the real world with little or no end in sight, the digital battles online are bound to follow.

Industry
Canadian BlackBerry maker Research In Motion enjoyed a rare surge in stock value this week as shares jumped as much as 10% on the back of a rumor that South Korea's Samsung may be interested in buying the struggling mobile phone company. The joy for BlackBerry investors was short-lived, as Samsung released a statement on Wednesday claiming that the company hasn't considered acquiring the RIM and is not interested in buying it.

RIM been struggling to maintain a viable place in a market increasingly consumed by Google and Apple and their burgeoning online app stores.

Note
1. For the Google petition, see here.

Martin J Young is an Asia Times Online correspondent based in Thailand.
FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×