Skip to main content

Reply to "Why did the PPP go to India? - Malcolm Harripaul."

Billy Ram Balgobin posted:
Zed posted:

Cain, no, I am not denying that the PPP and some of its leaders did not lean towards communism or socialism. My point is that the governments headed by the PPP were in no way communist or socialist. At most, one might want to categorize the Jagan led government prior to Jagdeo after 1992 as social democrat.

Furthermore, I remind you that in the time of Cheddi and Janet Jagan going into politics and the formation of the PPP, the anti-colonial struggle was underway and then and later many of the persons leading the fight for national liberation in the colonies were propagating the “non-capitalist path” to economic, social, cultural  development and colonial freedom. During that time many of these individuals and parties had close fraternal  relations with the Soviet Union, China and Cuba. If the argument is that they received aid from these countries as they struggled for national liberation and economic development, then one has to remember the context of the struggle, that on the other side of the struggle, the colonial and new-colonial powers were actively supporting repressive dictatorships and those in colonies who promoted continued colonial and economic  domination, that poverty and its associated ills were rampant for the vast majority of the peoples of Asia, South America, Central America, Africa the West and East Indies.

Even Churchill and Roosevelt acknowledged the great sacrifices the Soviet Union made in fighting and defeating German Fascism. The Germans concentrated 2/3 of their forces on the Eastern front. The Soviet Union lost almost 30 million lives.   The Soviet people took aid from America in battling the Nazis.  Maybe Harripaul should charge the US for selling out to communism during the War.

The man is a moron. 

Bill Bal.  The Soviets lost millions of people during the second world war not because they were anti- white and believed in equality but because the Germans never accepted them as Aryan brothers.  When the Germans invaded the Soviet union many Soviet citizens greeted them as liberators.  It was only after they realized that the Germans had rejected them and saw them as a non-Aryan slave people that the Soviets started to fight the Germans.

Prashad
×
×
×
×
×
×