Skip to main content

Reply to "Daddy's Lil girl Ivanka"

Prashad posted:

I asked a jew about five years ago why they selected Palestine to go there after WW2 instead of the Rupanununi in Guyana. He said Israel is their historical land. They have a connection to it. I think to myself then that this is just like how Han Chinese think about Tibet and Muslim parts of China. And just like how some Hindus feel about Kashmir.

"Historical Land". How do you arbitrarily decide to select a piece of land from "that mountain" to "that sea", move people who have living there for thousands of years and settle there because your ancestors lived there thousands of years ago? Can any of us go claim land wherever our ancestors came from? The Jews have been persecuted and have a right to homes and eventually a homeland. Why not give initially give them back the land and homes the Nazis (and Soviets) drove them out of and set up some kind of gradual repatriation if they still wish to their ancestral homeland to areas that are unpopulated or come to some kind of agreement/reparation with the people living there.

GTAngler
×
×
×
×
×
×