Skip to main content

Reply to "We tested 5 pre-made chocolate chip cookie doughs and figured out the only brand worth buying"

Phase Two: Pre-cut Dough

Nestle and Pillsbury each also offer a flat package of chocolate chip cookie dough that's already rolled out and measured for you, saving the extra steps of guestimating what a "teaspoonful" is and rolling it into a ball.

Here's what each brand's ready-made dough looks like right out of the package:

Nestle vs. Pillsbury pre cut cookie dough right out of packaging _edited 1
Interesting packaging difference. Which do you prefer?
Sydney Kramer/INSIDER

There's a stark difference between the two.

Nestle's dough had a darker brown appearance, and a lot more visible chocolate chips. The dough was almost packaged more compactly and in squares.

Pillsbury's dough was a lot more pale, with fewer chips and a larger cardboard container. The dough was separated more and had rounded edges.

Nestle vs. Pillsbury pre cut dough on parchment
Nestle's chocolate chip game is already winning us over.
Sydney Kramer/INSIDER

We chose NOT to manually roll the pre-cut chunks into smooth balls, since the point of this type is that it require fewer steps, right?

The Nestle cubes broke off relatively easily, though a few times the squares would come apart unevely. Pillsbury's rounded rectangles were much easier to pull apart.

We placed the pre-cut dough into a 350° oven and set the timer for another 11 minutes.

FM
×
×
×
×
×
×